How to read the comparison
Not sure how the working arrangements differ? Read our contractor vs employee NZ guide for tax responsibilities, paid leave and employment rights.
Employment usually means PAYE is handled automatically, income is more predictable, and paid leave may be available. Contracting can increase flexibility and let you claim business expenses, but you need to manage tax, ACC, admin time, and income gaps yourself.
For a deeper contractor view, try the Self-Employed Tax Calculator. For salary and wage detail, use the PAYE Calculator.
Employee KiwiSaver is deducted automatically. Contractor retirement saving is voluntary, so this page includes a matching contractor saving input to make the cash comparison fairer.
Paid leave and billable weeks
An annual employee salary already includes paid annual holidays. Employees generally qualify for at least four weeks after 12 months of continuous employment, plus paid public holidays that fall on otherwise working days. We do not add leave to salary or deduct it again.
Contractors usually cannot bill for time off. Enter the weeks and hours you expect to invoice, leaving room for holidays, public holidays, sick days, admin and gaps between jobs. The starting 46 weeks and 35 hours are editable planning examples, not legal rules or a prediction of your workload.
In annual revenue mode, enter your expected full-year revenue after allowing for unpaid time. Changing billable hours or weeks then changes the hourly-rate comparison only, not that annual revenue. All weekly cash results are annual totals divided by 52, including unpaid weeks.
Two comparisons: take-home cash is the money left to spend. Cash plus retirement adds your own saving back once and includes the employer KiwiSaver contribution after ESCT. It does not count the gross employer payment twice, or treat retirement money as cash you can spend now. Government KiwiSaver contributions, investment returns, fees and withdrawal eligibility are not modelled.
Leave guidance: Employment New Zealand annual holidays and public holiday rights.
Calculation notes
Tax code: this page does not ask for a tax code because it is comparing annual outcomes, not recreating a payroll run. Tax codes can change PAYE withholding during the year, but the final annual income tax usually follows the personal tax brackets for the year.
Student loan: employee deductions use an annualised main-job estimate. Contractor repayments use the end-of-year rules, including the $500 adjusted-net-income and income-over-threshold tests. Other income and individual adjustments are not modelled here.
Rates: income tax brackets, student loan settings, ACC caps, ESCT bands and KiwiSaver options come from shared tax-year data. Employee ACC uses the payroll rate. The contractor allowance uses ACC's before-GST Earners' rate, adding unrecoverable GST for a non-registered sole trader.
Contractor ACC: the default is a partial planning allowance on profit before ACC, not a complete CoverPlus invoice. It excludes Work and Working Safer levies and does not apply full-time minimum earnings. ACC applies minimum liable earnings to full-time work (more than 30 hours a week on average, including non-billable work); billable hours alone cannot establish this. Use an official quote or invoice for full costs, classification, experience rating, part-year work or CoverPlus Extra. The annual invoice amount stays fixed when solving break-even rates; get a new quote if expected earnings change.
ACC and tax: this is a New Zealand-resident sole-trader comparison, not a company/shareholder-employee or combined-income model. Self-employed levies reduce taxable profit and cash once. Enter only levies attributable to this tax year, after GST recovery. Invoice timing can differ from the year the underlying earnings were earned. Do not include those levies again in expenses. The allowance's tax deduction is a planning estimate; your return must use the appropriate actual invoice deduction.
GST and expenses: choose your actual registration status; it is not changed automatically. Registered users can enter standard-rated, fully claimable revenue/operating expenses including 15% GST, or use GST-exclusive totals. GST collected is removed from income and recoverable purchase GST is removed from expenses. Non-registered users enter actual amounts without removing GST. For mixed, exempt, zero-rated or partly claimable items, use correctly adjusted GST-exclusive figures instead. Other cash costs reduce cash but not taxable profit. Capital purchases and depreciation are not calculated here. This is not a GST return.
Employer KiwiSaver and ESCT: compulsory eligibility generally means a contributing member aged 18-64 historically, or 16-64 from 1 April 2026. A 0% employee deduction normally means no compulsory employer contribution; use agreed voluntary payments if applicable. A total-remuneration amount is split into salary and gross employer contribution, rather than adding the contribution again. This assumes a valid agreement; employer contributions must not reduce pay below minimum wage. For non-members or savings suspensions, enter your actual offered salary: do not assume an unused employer contribution will be paid as salary. ESCT uses the selected year's bands and the previous full year's salary plus gross employer contributions if entered, otherwise a current-year projection. This annual estimate does not reproduce payday whole-dollar rounding, contributions taxed under PAYE instead, or part-year eligibility changes.
IETC: optional eligible months default to 0; do not select them without checking residence, benefit and Working for Families restrictions for that year. The credit uses each scenario's taxable income and cannot exceed its income tax. For 2024-25, old and new bands are weighted by 121/365 and 244/365, then multiplied by eligible months / 12. Later years use the full current bands. Other income and losses brought forward are not modelled.
Break-even rates: the lowest whole-cent hourly rates that match either employee take-home cash or cash plus retirement, using the displayed settings. Rates use your selected GST input basis and allow for fixed annual expenses and other cash costs. Invoice-mode ACC is fixed; default ACC is incomplete. These are planning estimates, not recommended market rates.
Official guidance: ACC levies and classification, IRD ESCT rules, and GST registration.
Retirement saving: contractor saving is a voluntary percentage of revenue, not taxable profit. An approved 3% employee temporary reduction lasts 3 to 12 months; if it covers only part of the year, this constant-rate annual estimate will differ from actual deductions.
Disclaimer
This calculator provides estimates only. Tax, ACC, KiwiSaver, and student loan deductions may vary depending on your situation. For accurate advice, consult a professional.
Return to the TaxPop homepage.